By force of habit we tend to assume computers are made of silicon, but
there is actually no necessary connection between the machine and the
material. All that an engineer needs to do to make a computer is to find
a way to build logic gates -- the elementary building blocks of digital
computers -- in whatever material is handy.
So logic gates could theoretically be made of pipes of water, channels for billiard balls or even mazes for soldier crabs.
By comparison Tae Seok Moon's ambition, which is to build logic gates
out of genes, seems eminently practical. As a postdoctoral fellow in
the lab of Christopher Voigt, PhD, a synthetic biologist at the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, he recently made the largest gene
(or genetic) circuit yet reported.
Moon, PhD, now an assistant professor of energy, environmental and
chemical engineering in the School of Engineering & Applied Science
at Washington University in St. Louis is the lead author of an article
describing the project in the Oct. 7 issue of Nature. Voigt is the senior author.
The tiny circuits constructed from these gene gates and others like
them may one day be components of engineered cells that will monitor and
respond to their environments.
The number of tasks they could undertake is limited only by evolution
and human ingenuity. Janitor bacteria might clean up pollutants,
chemical-engineer bacteria pump out biofuels and miniature
infection-control bacteria might bustle about killing pathogens.
How to make an AND gate out of genes
The basis of modern computers is the logic gate, a device that makes
simple comparisons between the bits, the 1s and 0s, in which computers
encode information. Each logic gate has multiple inputs and one output.
The output of the gate depends on the inputs and the operation the gate
performs.
An AND gate, for example, turns on only if all of its inputs are on. An OR gate turns on if any of its inputs are on.
Suggestively, genes are turned on or off when a transcription factor
binds to a region of DNA adjacent to the gene called a promotor.
To make an AND gate out of genes, however, Moon had to find a gene
whose activation is controlled by at least two molecules, not one. So
only if both molecule 1 AND molecule 2 are present will the gene be
turned on and translated into protein.
Such a genetic circuit had been identified in Salmonella typhimurium,
the bacterium that causes food poisoning. In this circuit, the
transcription factor can bind to the promotor of a gene only if a
molecule called a chaperone is present. This meant the genetic circuit
could form the basis of a two-input AND gate.
The circuit Moon eventually built consisted of four sensors for four
different molecules that fed into three two-input AND gates. If all four
molecules were present, all three AND gates turned on and the last one
produced a reporter protein that fluoresced red, so that the operation
of the circuit could be easily monitored.
In the future, Moon says, a synthetic bacterium with this circuit
might sense four different cancer indicators and, in the presence of all
four, release a tumor-killing factor.
Crosstalk and timing faults
There are huge differences, of course, between the floppy molecules
that embody biological logic gates and the diodes and transistors that
embody electronic ones.
Engineers designing biological circuits worry a great deal about
crosstalk, or interference. If a circuit is to work properly, the
molecules that make up one gate cannot bind to molecules that are part
of another gate.
This is much more of a problem in a biological circuit than in an
electronic circuit because the interior of a cell is a kind of soup
where molecules mingle freely.
To ensure that there wouldn't be crosstalk among his AND gates, Moon
mined parts for his gates from three different strains of bacteria: Shigella flexneri and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, as well as Salmonella.
Although the parts from the three different strains were already
quite dissimilar, he made them even more so by subjecting them to
error-prone copying cycles and screening the copies for ones that were
even less prone to crosstalk (but still functional).
Another problem Moon faced is that biological circuits, unlike
electronic ones, don't have internal clocks that keep the bits moving
through the logic gates in lockstep. If signals progress through layers
of gates at different speeds, the output of the entire circuit may be
wrong, a problem called a timing fault.
Experiments designed to detect such faults in the synthetic circuit
showed that they didn't occur, probably because the chaperones for one
layer of logic gates degrades before the transcription factors for the
next layer are generated, and this forces a kind of rhythm on the
circuit.
Hijacking a bacterium's controller
"We're not trying to build a computer out of biological logic gates,"
Moon says. "You can't build a computer this way. Instead we're trying
to make controllers that will allow us to access all the things
biological organisms do in simple, programmable ways."
"I see the cell as a system that consists of a sensor, a controller
(the logic circuit), and an actuator," he says. "This paper covers work
on the controller, but eventually the controller's output will drive an
actuator, something that will do work on the cell's surroundings. "
An synthetic bacterium designed by a friend of Moon's at Nanyang
Technological University in Singapore senses signaling molecules
released by the pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa. When the
molecules reach a high enough concentration, the bacterium generates a
toxin and a protein that causes it to burst, releasing the toxin, and
killing nearby P. aeruginosa.
"Silicon cannot do that," Moon says.
Journal Reference:
- Tae Seok Moon, Chunbo Lou, Alvin Tamsir, Brynne C. Stanton, Christopher A. Voigt. Genetic programs constructed from layered logic gates in single cells. Nature, 2012; DOI: 10.1038/nature11516
Courtesy: ScienceDaily